Great Yarmouth murder trial: pubs and pool league ban for jurors

PUBLISHED: 06:30 05 March 2013

Bricklayers Arms pub on Nelson Road Central and Victoria Road in Great Yarmouth.

Bricklayers Arms pub on Nelson Road Central and Victoria Road in Great Yarmouth.

Archant Norfolk Photographic © 2013

Five people accused of murdering a man outside a Great Yarmouth pub face a six-week trial, Norwich Crown Court heard yesterday.

Victim Ian Church, 40, was attacked in the street near the Bricklayers Arms in the early hours of May 5, 2012.

He died at the James Paget University Hospital (JPH) in Gorleston two days later.

Three men from Yarmouth and a man and woman from Kent stand accused of murder after the incident in Nelson Road Central - a charge they all deny.

And Judge Peter Jacobs heard how a web of Yarmouth pubs and pool teams, along with up to 39 individuals to be named in the case, mean a verdict is unlikely to be reached before mid-April.

The defendants are Yarmouth men Todd Esherwood, 24, of Saxon Road, Tony Smith, 29, of Sidney Close, Stuart Layden, 30, of South Quay and Kent pair Kelly Taylor, 33, of Harris Road, Sheerness and Roy Smith, 31, of Ranelagh Road, Sheerness.

Esherwood is also charged with ABH, and Tony Smith, Taylor and Layden face a joint ABH charge.

Judge Jacobs said: “This trial is hoped to complete by mid-April, but could go on until the end of the month.”

Potential jurors were barred from joining the jury if they mixed in certain circles in Yarmouth.

Nicola May, for the prosecution, said regulars of eight named Yarmouth pubs could not become jurors in the trial.

These were the Pier Tavern at Britannia Pier, the Suspension Bridge, The Recruit, The Jockey, The Recruiting Sergeant, Merlin’s Sports Bar, the Alexandra pub and the Bricklayers Arms.

Ms May added involvement with the Carling Winter pool league would rule potential jurors out.

And they must not have any connection with three named pool teams – the Apollo Tavern, the Duke of Wellington and the Jockey Club.

The public gallery was packed with family members of the defendants as the 12-strong jury was selected at random and sworn in, along with two reserves.

No evidence was heard yesterday, as the jury was allowed to go for the day and legal wrangles were heard.

The prosecution will outline its case this morning as the case continues.

Other News

34 minutes ago

More than £500,000 was spent on sending patients under the care of the region’s mental health trust to other facilities in the last month as bosses admit “still too many” patients were being sent out of the area for treatment.


Plans to rejuvenate the area around Great Yarmouth’s railway station have been given a seal of approval.


A north Norfolk GP practice has been ranked among the best in the country after being rated outstanding by the independent regulator of health and social care.

Usually journalists are the ones asking the questions, however the shoe was on the other foot at a village school.

Most Read

Mon, 17:23

A man in his 20s who was hit by a car in Bradwell died just two hours later, it has emerged.

Read more
James Paget University Hospital
Yesterday, 12:17

The family of the 22-year-old man who died in a road accident in Bradwell on Friday have paid tribute to a “comical little lad”.

Read more
James Paget University Hospital

There were dramatic scenes after a fire that destroyed three sheds caused a number of gas canisters to explode in Great Yarmouth.

Read more
Yesterday, 13:04

A 20-year-old man from Great Yarmouth has been remanded in custody this morning after being charged with the rape of a girl under 16 in a Lowestoft park, sexual grooming her and breaching a sexual harm prevention order. Christopher Neill, of Marsh Road, was arrested by Suffolk police officers on Monday after the girl reported that she had been raped in Fen Park on Sunday after meeting a man she had contact with on Facebook.

Read more
Tue, 14:05

A group of police officers who fought a road side life and death battle to save a Great Yarmouth stabbing victim from bleeding to death are to receive top national life-saving honours.

Read more
Norfolk Police

Most Commented


Plans to rejuvenate the area around Great Yarmouth’s railway station have been given a seal of approval.

Read more
Graham Plant
Yesterday, 13:41

The delights of an early summer seaside break in Great Yarmouth are being featured in a television advert targeting potential tourists in four counties.

Read more

A Gorleston school has been praised by the schools minister as one of the country’s top primaries.

Read more

A petition has been set up calling for a soup kitchen to be granted a licence to operate in Great Yarmouth.

Read more
Graham Plant
Tue, 15:45

Organisers of an air show have defended their decision to cancel their plans for this year.

Read more
Barry Coleman

Local Weather

Partly Cloudy

Partly Cloudy

max temp: 20°C

min temp: 11°C


Show Job Lists

Digital Edition


Enjoy the Great
Yarmouth Mercury

e-edition today


Newsletter Sign Up

Sign up to receive our regular email newsletter