Search

Nearly £3m spent on gagging orders for departing staff from Norfolk, Suffolk and Cambridgeshire councils

PUBLISHED: 09:49 21 April 2017 | UPDATED: 14:11 21 April 2017

Cllr George Nobbs (pictured),  leader of the Labour group on the county council, 
Cllr Toby Coke, chairman of the Environment, Development and Transport Committee and Tom McCabe, executive director of Community and Environmental Services brief the media on the latest news for the Norwich NDR at County Hall.
Picture by SIMON FINLAY.

Cllr George Nobbs (pictured), leader of the Labour group on the county council, Cllr Toby Coke, chairman of the Environment, Development and Transport Committee and Tom McCabe, executive director of Community and Environmental Services brief the media on the latest news for the Norwich NDR at County Hall. Picture by SIMON FINLAY.

Nearly £3m of taxpayers’ money has been used to pay off departing council staff in controversial settlements which include gagging orders.

Great Yarmouth Borough Council  Conservative leader 
Graham Plant.

Picture: James BassGreat Yarmouth Borough Council Conservative leader Graham Plant. Picture: James Bass

Freedom of Information requests showed compromise or settlement agreements have been used more than 200 times by councils in our region since 2013,

They are being used when people have been sacked, made redundant or left due to “workplace issues”, despite the government saying such measures, with confidentiality clauses, should only be used in “extreme circumstances”.

Through such voluntary agreements, staff get a severance payment and agree to not make a tribunal claim and the confidentiality element prevents them speaking about their former employers.

The councils have not released details of which members of staff signed such agreements.

Compromise or settlement agreements have proved controversial. Pic: Nick Ansell/PA WireCompromise or settlement agreements have proved controversial. Pic: Nick Ansell/PA Wire

Norfolk County Council paid out £184,555 to six people in 2016/17 – a year in which the director of children’s services Michael Rosen left the authority soon after the leadership of his department was criticised by Ofsted inspectors.

The county council said all six settlements were paid to resolve “workplace issues”. The total paid was almost £80,000 more than for the previous two years, when there were eight agreements.

George Nobbs, leader of the Labour group at County Hall said he did not think the mechanism should be used so frequently.

He said: “It seems that, under the current administration, confidentiality agreements, 
or gagging orders as they are more properly known, have become the management tool of choice. It begs the question of just what it is about the way the council is currently run that 
they do not want people to talk about?”

The council said the use of the agreements saved money, by avoiding legal disputes.

A spokesman said: “It is imperative that we have the right people in post to provide the high quality services the people of Norfolk want and expect.

“There are times when we need to make changes quickly, without the need for lengthy and costly legal discussions – which would be far more expensive than reaching a mutual settlement.

“We must adhere to employment rights and entitlements and come to an agreement that has the least financial impact on the council.

“As funding reduces year on year, it becomes more necessary to make changes, to ensure services are sustainable and that we have the right staff in place to tackle the challenges faced across local government.”

The Department for Communities and Local Government last year said confidentiality clauses should only be used in “extreme circumstances” and not “stop, stifle or control individuals from speaking out about concerns about their employer”.

The authority which has used the agreements most frequently – and with so much money attached – over the past four years is Great Yarmouth Borough Council, which used them 57 times – a total of more than £820,000.

Leader Graham Plant said their use had been cut since he became leader of the authority in 2015 and set up a new management team.

In a statement, the council said, as part of ways to save money without making cuts to services, it had previously looked at its workforce.

The statement said: “Around four to five years ago, the council offered all staff the option to express an interest in voluntary departure on the grounds of efficiency improvements and entering into settlement agreements.

“In the last two years, the number of agreements have reduced significantly and are only used in exceptional circumstances.

“At the time, these agreements enabled a swift and dignified exit to the employment relationship, avoiding time, cost and stress to both parties in a tribunal claim, and they often included the provision of employment references.

“They also provided certainty to the council as it aims to resolve all or any outstanding disputes and to prevent any future claim against the council.

“These settlements must be 
seen in the context of the ongoing year-on-year savings of deleting these posts.”

3 comments

  • Pink trousers I wonder umm

    Add your comment | Report this comment

    PaulH

    Sunday, April 23, 2017

  • "Only saying" poster is incorrect. Cllr George Nobbs (Labour Group) was replaced by Cllr Cliff Jordan (Conservatives) at the helm of Norfolk County Council in May 2016 (so he was not in charge for "most of 201617"), after the Green Party group (all four of them including one who has now joined the Tories) decided to throw their toys out of the pram and wreck the rainbow alliance at County Hall. I think it interesting that Archant decided to head this report with a photo of Mr Nobbs rather than Mr Jordan. I wonder what they are trying to suggest?

    Add your comment | Report this comment

    Red Steepler

    Friday, April 21, 2017

  • George Nobbs seems quick to blame the current administration but conveniently forgets that for most of 201617 he was at the helm of a rudderless ship. It is only relatively recently that the Conservatives have taken control.

    Add your comment | Report this comment

    Only saying..

    Friday, April 21, 2017

The views expressed in the above comments do not necessarily reflect the views of this site

Welcome , please leave your message below.

Optional - JPG files only
Optional - MP3 files only
Optional - 3GP, AVI, MOV, MPG or WMV files
Comments

Please log in to leave a comment and share your views with other Great Yarmouth Mercury visitors.

We enable people to post comments with the aim of encouraging open debate.

Only people who register and sign up to our terms and conditions can post comments. These terms and conditions explain our house rules and legal guidelines.

Comments are not edited by Great Yarmouth Mercury staff prior to publication but may be automatically filtered.

If you have a complaint about a comment please contact us by clicking on the Report This Comment button next to the comment.

Not a member yet?

Register to create your own unique Great Yarmouth Mercury account for free.

Signing up is free, quick and easy and offers you the chance to add comments, personalise the site with local information picked just for you, and more.

Sign up now

Other News

Yesterday, 20:02

An independent ambulance service used in the region has suspended offering urgent care after it was hit with a long list of issues by health inspectors, including finding bodily fluids on equipment.

Yesterday, 18:46

A heroic pensioner has described how he was dragged along a street as he fought to stop an out-of-control lorry.

Yesterday, 16:32

Who can we trust at the ballot box?

Yesterday, 16:15

A motorbike rider was taken to hospital after a crash in Ormesby St Margaret.

Most Read

Wed, 07:52

A 23-year-old student is disputing a PIP decision that has stripped him of his mobility car.

Read more
United Kingdom
Wed, 14:23

Police and firefighters conducted an emergency search of Great Yarmouth’s Waterways, after responding to reports that a person’s hand was seen in the water.

Read more
Tue, 08:50

A reinforcement of uniform rules has seen more than a dozen youngsters told not to wear trainers for school in less than a week.

Read more
Flegg High School
Tue, 13:37

Channel 4’s on-demand platform All 4 is set to film part of their latest show, Lee & Dean, in Great Yarmouth.

Read more
Norwich
Tue, 21:01

A girl was treated by an air ambulance crew after she suffered a head injury in an accident involving a horse.

Read more
James Paget Hospital

Local Weather

Partly Cloudy

Partly Cloudy

max temp: 10°C

min temp: 0°C

HOT JOBS

Show Job Lists

Digital Edition

cover

Enjoy the Great
Yarmouth Mercury

e-edition today

Subscribe

Newsletter Sign Up

Sign up to receive our regular email newsletter